Opinion: Agree
Comment
by Byrne, Durham (26 Sep 08 15:59)
about
this REVIEW.
We have been on this ship (MSC ORCHESTRA) in January this year and understand what you are talking about as said below . dont think cruising is always like that. You should try OCEAN VILLAGE or even better Island Star out of Majorca. you can book Cruise Only for about £450 a week. We have just been on Island Star for two weeks (6th to 20th September). Some people (as Mr Burrows say THINK this is at the lower end of the market) Its not really as the food is just as good as the big ships leaving Southampton . More casual though and better atmosphere and a pint of Stella for £2.80. and 24 hour dining without being stuck with the same people each evening. Dress standards are applied to some restaurants ie NO SHORTS in evenings Have been on 10 cruises and the last one was nearly perfect. Horses for courses as they say ....happy cruising.
Report this comment
Opinion: Agree
Comment
by Burrows, Southampton (17 Aug 08 19:48)
about
this REVIEW.
A very unfortunate choice for your first cruise I am afraid. As previously mentioned, all of the problems that you detailed with this cruise are already well documented on this site. It is a real shame that you did not do a bit of research before booking this cruise. Most MSC cruise publicity at the moment is plastered with "Children free all year", which is enough to set alarm bells ringing with most of us for a start off! Although a lot of people are suggesting that you try a cruise with a British line, I don't think that many of them have cottoned on to the fact that you are lucky enough to live in Almeria, Spain! Not the most convenient place to jump onto a P&O ship really? Unless you fancy trying a fjords or Baltic cruise, I think the flight to Britain would be rather a waste of time and money? I would stick to cruising out of Barcelona with either Royal Caribbean or Celebrity. Alternatively, you could get a short flight from Murcia or Alicante over to Palma where you can experience the likes of Ocean Village, Thomson and Island cruises. All providing a very British cruise experience, though all at the lower end of the sophistication market, so long as you don't mind that? Whatever you do, don't let this one bad experience colour your view of cruising completely. Not many people are fortunate enough to have a PERFECT cruise, but most are a damn site better than yours! Happy cruising.
Report this comment
Comment
by Byrne, Birmingham (15 Aug 08 09:50)
about
this REVIEW.
What a shame you didn't enjoy your cruise but please don't let it put you off for life as there are some wonderful cruise ships out there. P&O, Royal Caribbean, Princess etc. They can be busy but in a good way. Some P&O ships are child free if you want that and the food is excellent as is the entertainment and the staff. The best people to ask about ports of call are the casino staff as they have the most free time in the day and have usually done all sightseeing and will tell you where to go and where to get the the cheap local buses,taxis, trains etc. We very rarely use the ships excursions except if you feel a bit unsafe ie some of the the caribbean islands. Do your homework and ask plenty of questions but don't give up after one cruise.
Report this comment
Comment
by Wilba, N (15 Aug 08 07:51)
about
this REVIEW.
What a shame! Here you are writing a review about a bad experience, when all the information you needed was freely available on this site by reading the review section that you are now on. You could of even asked for advice as to whether MSC would meet your criteria & expectations. Everyone of your gripes could have flagged up to you before you bought the tickets, & as for 'Shopping Trip' tours, they are a complete no no on any cruise line. There are a number of 'rated' cruise lines out there with no where near the negatives that MSC, & others, have to offer. As others have said, give it a fair chance, go to a Cruise Specialist who knows the business & can give proper advice, not some silly bird in a High St travel shop who wouldn't know a cruise ship if it landed in her bathtub.
Report this comment
Opinion: Disagree
Comment
by Dobson, Holme Upon Spalding Moor (14 Aug 08 19:25)
about
this REVIEW.
Do you always have a 'never again' attitude when you come across something that is not to your taste?
How can you make a final decision about cruising based on one ship, one holiday, one cruise line? No doubt you had a bad time of it. But all you have to do is read reviews from other cruise ships and you'll find that they aren't all the same.
Try another company. Cunard, P & O, Princess, Royal Caribbean are all top rated cruise lines and have plenty of positive comments about their ships and itineries. Don't give up on cruising because of one ship. You'll be silly if you do.
Report this comment
Comment
by Farr, Huercal Overa (15 Aug 08 01:05)
about
a COMMENT by Dobson (14 Aug 08 19:25)
No,I do not have a "never again" attitude to anything. The problem I have is that cruising is quite expensive and I do not wish to make the same mistake again. I cannot say that we had a bad time. Just that it was not what I had expected. One goes on holiday to have a good time and relax and should finish that holiday feeling that those two simple goals should have been achieved, That was simply not the case with this particular cruise line. Perhaps if we had booked with a British Cpmpany things might have been different?
Report this comment
Comment
by Dobson, Holme Upon Spalding Moor (15 Aug 08 09:05)
about
a COMMENT by Farr (15 Aug 08 01:05)
Now that you've included a review of a cruise you'll hopefully receive a free Berlitz guide to cruising in the next few weeks. Take your tips from the guide. I found most of it spot on for Sea and Crown Princess. It also tells you the top 10 cruise lines to try.
I agree cruises can (are!) expensive and understand the reluctancy to spend again on another cruise. I also agree that when you're cruising for the first time to stick with either a British or American cruise line as these have a better reputation. They aren't always necessarily the most expensive either. Book through a cruise specialist. We've always used cruisefinders on the internet. But there are other good agents too. We've sailed the Caribbean twice and are going again March 2010. We've never paid more than £1400 each for any of our cruises and that was for 14 nights (15 if you include the flight back!) aboard Crown and Sea Princess; both excellent ships. Though Sea Princess is geared more more us Brits! Give it another try! You don't get put off going to hotels when 'one' has a not-so-good time of it. Or do you?
Report this comment
Opinion: Disagree
Comment
by Reynolds, Lincoln (14 Aug 08 18:22)
about
this REVIEW.
Not all cruise lines are like this, P & O for example only suggest what to tip it is not automatically added to your onboard spends. I think the success of picking the right ship is to read all the brochures, particularly the small print then talk to a good travel agent, preferably one that specialises in cruises.
Report this comment
Comment
by Farr, Huercal Overa (15 Aug 08 01:11)
about
a COMMENT by Reynolds (14 Aug 08 18:22)
If all cruise ships were like the MSC Orchestra then the whole industry would collapse.
I did tip very generously but only to those who deserved it. In fact if I had relied on the cruise company´s guideline of twelve euros per day I would have saved quite a bit of money. I suppose the mistake that I made was to book over the internet and tom take with a pinch of salt the negative comments. Perhaps we will go again but next time with a British Company!
Report this comment
Comment
by branham, bromley (15 Aug 08 15:15)
about
a COMMENT by Farr (15 Aug 08 01:11)
Entirely agreed that a british company would suit you far better. If you like informality and perhaps are faced with budgetary constraints then Thompson, Island Cruises, or Ocean Village might fit the bill. Given your age demographic, I would hesitate before recommending Fred. Olsen although they, like P&O, would be a good fit if you are more inclined towards a more formal traditional approach. Cunard also fits into this category. P&O also offers a choice between family friendly and child free ships. All in all, they might be the best choice.
Report this comment
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||



















